On the same day as the US begins an investigation into whether the 3% digital services tax (DST) adopted by the French is damaging to US businesses with a view to taking retaliatory action, the UK publishes for consultation draft legislation and draft guidance to implement the UK's DST. Both DSTs are intended to be a temporary response to political pressure to act now and will be disapplied once an appropriate international solution to the problems of taxing the digitalised economy is in place.
Any long term solution should avoid double taxation and ensure profits, not revenues, are taxed. Any unilateral measure, however, cannot be based on profits because this would be in breach of treaty obligations. Nevertheless, the UK government considers the DST to be targeted and proportionate pending a longer term international settlement.
From April 2020, the UK government will introduce a 2% tax on the revenues of search engines, social media platforms and online marketplaces which derive value from UK users. Associated online advertising business is also in scope if operated on an online platform that facilitates the placing of online advertising and derives significant benefit from its connection with the social media platform, search engine or online marketplace. There is an exemption from the online marketplace definition for financial and payment services providers.
A key feature of the UK's DST is a UK user which is defined as any person "who it is reasonable to assume" is "normally in the UK" (if an individual) or "established in the UK" (if not an individual). It does not matter where the user is actually located at the time of the transaction. The onus is on the business to use the evidence available to it to determine whether it is reasonable to assume a user is a UK user. The draft guidance gives a non-exhaustive list of sources of evidence businesses commonly collect: delivery address, payment details, IP address, intended destination of advertising based on contractual evidence, address of property or location of goods which are rented out.
In order to ease double taxation, the revenue charged will be reduced to 50% of the revenues from the transaction when the other user in respect of the transaction is normally located in a country that operates a similar tax to the DST.
The DST will apply to in-scope businesses when the group’s worldwide revenues from these digital activities are more than £500m and more than £25m of these revenues are derived from UK users. If the group’s revenues exceed these thresholds, its revenues derived from UK users will be taxed at a rate of 2%. There is an allowance of £25m, which means a group’s first £25m of revenues derived from UK users will not be subject to DST.
Businesses will be able to elect to calculate the DST under an alternative calculation under the ‘safe harbour’ based on UK operating margin. This is to ensure that where a UK activity is loss making, no DST needs to be paid on revenues attributable to that activity.
The closing date for comments on the UK's DST is 5 September. Updated guidance will follow later in 2019 reflecting comments received during the consultation and the legislation at the time of publishing in Finance Bill 2020 in the Autumn.